Check Engine Light Is On But Car Runs Fine

If you’ve been a car driver for any length of time, you’ve probably experienced the frustration of seeing the check engine light turn on.

But what if your car is running perfectly fine despite the warning?

This is actually a common scenario that often leaves drivers confused and wondering what to do.

The check engine light can turn on even if the car runs fine due to a variety of reasons, such as a loose gas cap, faulty oxygen sensor, damaged catalytic converter, or a malfunctioning spark plug.

In this article, we’ll explore the possible causes of the check engine light turning on when your car runs fine. We’ll also discuss whether it’s safe to continue driving and what steps you can take to address the issue.

Car Running Fine Despite A Check Engine Warning Light?

The check engine light in a car can come on even if the vehicle appears to be running fine for several reasons. One common cause is a minor issue with one of the car’s many sensors, such as an oxygen sensor, mass airflow sensor or ABS sensor.

These sensors are designed to monitor various aspects of the engine’s performance and emissions, and can sometimes trigger the check engine light if they are starting to fail or if they are dirty.

The car’s ECU can detect potential problems that may not be immediately noticeable to the driver. In some cases, the issue might be intermittent or temporary, and the light can turn off on its own after a few drive cycles.

Another possibility is that the light has been triggered by a transient issue, such as a temporary dip in oil pressure or increased strain on the engine during towing. In these cases, the check engine light will serve as a warning of a potential problem, but not necessarily one that is currently affecting your car’s performance.

It’s also worth noting that the check engine light is a warning light that might not always provide a complete picture of your car’s condition. Although it serves as a valuable warning system, it’s not infallible and, in some cases, may not accurately represent the severity or nature of the problem.

While your car may seem to be running fine, it’s still important to address the check engine light if it stays on.

To get a more accurate assessment of the issue, you should perform an OBD-II scan on your vehicle. This will help to pinpoint the exact problem and provide guidance on what steps should be taken to resolve it.

What Exactly Is The Check Engine Light?

The check engine light, often abbreviated as “CEL” or “MIL” (Malfunction Indicator Lamp), is a warning light on the dashboard of a car that illuminates when the vehicle’s onboard system (OBD-II system) detects a potential issue with the engine, emissions, or related components.

The OBD-II system constantly monitors various sensors and systems in the vehicle, such as the engine, exhaust, fuel, and emissions systems. When the system detects a problem, it generates a fault code and activates the check engine light to alert the driver that something may be wrong.

There are many common reasons why the check engine light can turn on. Some of the most common causes include a loose fuel cap, a faulty oxygen sensor, a damaged catalytic converter, a malfunctioning spark plug, a faulty mass airflow sensor, or a damaged ignition coil.

Other potential causes include a malfunctioning thermostat, a damaged vacuum hose, or a failing battery.

When the check engine light comes on, the car’s computer stores a specific error code related to the issue, which can be accessed through an onboard diagnostics (OBD) scanner.

Mechanics and car enthusiasts can use this code to then pinpoint the problem and determine the appropriate course of action.

5 Common Causes for the Check Engine Light

The check engine light is a universal warning signal on your car’s dashboard that can indicate a variety of issues with a vehicle’s engine or other systems. While the light can be triggered for many different reasons, some causes are more common than others. In this section, we’ll explore the five most common causes of check engine light activation.

1. Loose or Damaged Gas Cap

One possible reason for the check engine light to be on, even when the car runs fine, is a loose or damaged gas cap. A gas cap that is not tight enough or has a cracked seal can cause fuel vapors to leak, leading to decreased fuel efficiency and increased emissions. In such cases, simply tightening the gas cap or replacing it can resolve the issue.

2. Malfunctioning Oxygen Sensor

A bad oxygen sensor may also result in the check engine light coming on. Oxygen (O2) sensors monitor the level of oxygen in the exhaust gases and help the engine control module (ECM) to adjust the air-fuel mixture for optimal performance and emissions.

A malfunctioning O2 sensor can cause poor fuel economy and increased emissions but may not immediately affect the car’s performance.

3. Failing Catalytic Converter

Another possible cause for the check engine light is a failing catalytic converter. The catalytic converter is responsible for reducing harmful emissions by converting them into less harmful gases.

A bad catalytic converter can lead to decreased engine performance, higher emissions, and may eventually cause the car to fail an emissions test. Often the only option to fix this problem is to replace the failing catalytic converter.

4. Faulty Ignition Coil

A faulty ignition coil can also trigger the check engine light. Ignition coils are responsible for providing the high voltage needed for the spark plugs to ignite the air-fuel mixture inside the engine cylinders.

If an ignition coil fails, it may cause misfires, reduced power, and decreased fuel efficiency, although the car might still run. Diagnosing and replacing a faulty ignition coil can help restore the engine’s performance.

5. Bad Spark Plugs

Lastly, bad spark plugs can also cause a check engine light. Spark plugs play an essential role in the combustion process and can affect fuel efficiency, engine performance, and emissions.

Worn-out or damaged spark plugs may cause misfires, poor acceleration, and reduced fuel economy. Replacing the bad spark plugs can improve the engine’s overall performance and prevent further issues.

Intermittent Symptoms With A Check Engine Light?

Sometimes when the check engine light comes on there may be intermittent symptoms that there is something wrong with the engine. These symptoms may happen when the engine is cold, or when you accelerate hard or when the engine is under heavy load.

Usually in this scenario, the symptoms will come and go, but the check engine light will stay on, even when the car is running fine.

Here are a few symptoms to watch out for:

  1. Intermittent Stalling: The car may stall or shut off unexpectedly while driving or idling, and then restart normally.
  2. Intermittent Misfires: The engine may misfire or run rough intermittently, causing a noticeable vibration or loss of power.
  3. Intermittent Hesitation: The car may hesitate or stumble while accelerating or driving at a consistent speed, and then resume normal operation.
  4. Intermittent Rough Shifting: The transmission may shift roughly or jerk intermittently, especially when changing gears.
  5. Intermittent Loss of Power: The car may experience a sudden loss of power or acceleration intermittently, and then resume normal operation.

Car Shaking or Misfiring

Car shaking or misfiring is another symptom that can come and go and be associated with a check engine light. When a car is shaking, it usually indicates that the engine is misfiring, causing an imbalance in the engine’s performance.

A P0300 code often accompanies engine misfires, signaling that there is a random or multiple cylinder misfire taking place. There are numerous reasons for car shaking or misfiring, such as faulty spark plugs, ignition coils, or fuel injectors.

If you notice these symptoms alongside the check engine light, it is important to have your car inspected by a mechanic. Ignoring these symptoms may lead to more costly repairs down the line or potentially damage other engine components.

Flashing Check Engine Light vs. Steady Check Engine Light

A flashing check engine light typically indicates a more severe problem compared to a steady check engine light. When the check engine light flashes, it often signifies a misfire or an issue with at least one of the engine’s cylinders not going through the combustion cycle properly.

This could result in unburned fuel and excess heat, potentially causing harm to the engine and the catalytic converter.

On the other hand, a steady check engine light often signifies that there is a less urgent issue that requires attention. It can range from minor problems, such as a faulty gas cap, to more complex issues, like a failing sensor. When the check engine light is steady, you should still schedule an appointment with your mechanic for a diagnostic checkup.

It is essential not to ignore a flashing check engine light, as it generally indicates a critical issue. Driving with a flashing check engine light can lead to severe damage to the engine, catalytic converter, or other components. In such situations, it is advised to bring your vehicle to a mechanic as soon as possible to identify and address the problem.

How To Troubleshoot and Repair A Check Engine Light (Even When Your Car Is Running Fine)

1. Use a Code Reader or Scan Tool

When the check engine light is on but the car is running fine, it’s essential that you take a closer look to try and diagnose the issue.

One option is to use a code reader or scan tool to extract trouble codes stored in the vehicle’s computer. These devices can help pinpoint the cause of the problem and save time when identifying and repairing it. Plug the code reader or scan tool into the car’s diagnostic port (usually located under the dashboard), and follow the prompts.

The device will display specific trouble codes, which can be looked up online or in the manual provided with the tool. Understanding these codes is crucial in identifying the issue behind the check engine light. Some common issues include loose or leaking gas caps and faulty sensors.

2. Auto Parts Store Assistance

Many auto parts stores offer free assistance with diagnosing check engine light issues. The store may have professionals on-site who can help read the trouble codes and decipher their meanings.

They can also recommend appropriate replacement parts and provide guidance in resolving the issue. It’s essential to keep in mind that while the staff can provide valuable advice, they may not be able to replace parts or perform extensive repairs.

3. Consulting a Professional Technician

If the cause of the check engine light remains unclear after using a code reader or seeking assistance from an auto parts store, it’s best to consult a professional technician. A certified mechanic will have access to advanced diagnostic equipment and the expertise required to identify and fix the issue.

They can perform a thorough inspection, identify any underlying problems, and recommend appropriate repairs.

In some cases, the reason behind the check engine light might not significantly impact the vehicle’s performance. However, it’s essential to address any issues promptly to avoid causing further damage and ensure the car remains safe and efficient to operate.

If you have worked on your car before and have some knowledge of engines and access to some tools, there are a few other things you can check:

1. Check The Mass Airflow Sensor

The mass airflow sensor (MAF) measures the amount of air entering the engine to calculate the proper amount of fuel needed for optimal performance. If the MAF sensor is dirty or malfunctioning, it can lead to the check engine light coming on even if your car runs fine.

Inspecting and cleaning the MAF sensor can fix a check engine light and ensure accurate air flow readings and maintain proper fuel to air ratio.

2. Inspect And Clean The Fuel Injectors

Another potential cause for the check engine light could be your car’s fuel injectors. These components are responsible for delivering fuel to the engine, and any issues related to them, such as clogging or leaks, can lead to the check engine light illuminating.

When you carry out a diagnostic check using an OBD reader, you may uncover some DTCs associated with faulty fuel injectors. Here are some common bad fuel injector engine codes that may trigger a check engine light:

  1. P0171 – System Too Lean (Bank 1): This code indicates that the air-fuel mixture in the engine’s cylinders is too lean on the bank 1 side. A leaking fuel injector can introduce more air into the cylinders, leading to a lean condition.
  2. P0172 – System Too Rich (Bank 1): Conversely, this code indicates that the air-fuel mixture is too rich on the bank 1 side, which could be caused by a leaking fuel injector delivering excessive fuel to the cylinders.
  3. P0201 to P0208 – Injector Circuit/Open Cylinder X: These codes are specific to each cylinder and indicate an open circuit or malfunction in the fuel injector circuit. A leaking fuel injector can cause electrical issues, triggering these codes.
  4. P0300 – Random/Multiple Cylinder Misfire Detected: A leaking fuel injector can cause irregular fuel delivery, leading to misfires across multiple cylinders, which triggers this code.
  5. P0174 – System Too Lean (Bank 2): Similar to P0171 but affecting bank 2, this code indicates a lean condition due to a potential fuel injector leak on that side.
  6. P0175 – System Too Rich (Bank 2): Similar to P0172 but affecting bank 2, this code indicates a rich condition caused by a potential fuel injector leak on that side.

Inspecting and cleaning fuel injectors is best left to an expert. If you suspect that one or more injectors are leaking, then you should get a qualified mechanic or fuel injector expert to test them and refurbish them if necessary.

3. Fuel Tank and Air Filter

The check engine light will also indicate problems related to the fuel tank or air filter. Problems with the gas cap can easily cause the light to come on, as well as a clogged air filter causing improper air supply to the engine.

These problems are easy to check. If you find that the gas cap is not tightening properly or if the air filter is dirty then replacing them may help to fix the problem with the check engine light.

4. Check the condition and state of the battery

A bad battery can cause a check engine light to turn on due to its impact on the car’s electrical system. The car’s computer system relies on a stable power source to function properly, and a bad battery can cause fluctuations in voltage that can trigger the check engine light.

If the battery is not providing the correct voltage stream that the car’s computer needs to function properly, the check engine light can turn on.

If the check engine light is on, it’s important to diagnose the issue before checking the battery. However, if you suspect that the battery may be related to the check engine light, you can simply check the battery’s voltage using a multimeter. Here are the steps:

  1. Turn off the car: Make sure that the car is turned off and the key is removed from the ignition.
  2. Open the hood: Open the hood of the car and locate the battery.
  3. Connect the multimeter: Connect the multimeter to the battery terminals. The red lead should be connected to the positive terminal, and the black lead should be connected to the negative terminal.
  4. Set the multimeter: Set the multimeter to DC voltage mode and select a range that is higher than the battery’s voltage.
  5. Read the voltage: Read the voltage on the multimeter. A fully charged battery should read around 12.6 volts. If the voltage is significantly lower, the battery may be weak or discharged.

If the battery is weak or discharged, it may need to be charged or replaced. However, it’s important to diagnose the issue that triggered the check engine light before addressing the battery issue to prevent any potential damage to the car’s engine or emission system.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is the check engine light an emergency?

The check engine light is not always an emergency, but it should not be ignored. The light can indicate a variety of issues with a vehicle’s engine or other systems, ranging from minor issues like a loose gas cap to more severe problems like a damaged catalytic converter. While the car may still run fine with the check engine light on, ignoring the issue can lead to potential damage to the vehicle’s engine or emission system, which can be costly to repair. It’s important to have the issue diagnosed and repaired promptly to prevent any potential damage to the car.

2. Can bad gas cause the check engine light to come on?

Yes, bad gas can cause the check engine light to come on. If the fuel is contaminated or has an incorrect octane rating, it may not burn properly, causing the engine to misfire or run poorly. This can trigger the check engine light as the engine control module detects a problem in the combustion process.

3. Is it normal for a check engine light to turn off by itself?

In some cases, the check engine light may turn off by itself if the issue that triggered it is resolved or is no longer detected by the engine control module. For example, if the light was caused by a loose gas cap, tightening the cap may turn off the light. However, it is important to address any problems that may have caused the light to come on to ensure your vehicle is running efficiently.

4. What should I do when the check engine light comes on?

When the check engine light comes on, it’s important to take prompt action to diagnose and repair the issue. First, check the gas cap to ensure that it’s tight and secure. If there are no other obvious issues, consult the car’s manual for any information about the check engine light and what it may indicate. However, it’s recommended to take the car to a professional mechanic to have it diagnosed using a diagnostic tool to read the codes stored in the car’s computer system. Depending on the issue, you may be able to address it yourself or need to have it repaired by a professional mechanic. 

The motor guy author profile image

Author Bio